Sustaining Soil Organic Carbon and Soil Health in Intensively Tilled Short Crop Rotations

Abstract

Soils in Canada are under degradation due to the intensification of agricultural systems. Intensive field crop rotations are characterized by low crop diversity and crop residues, and high tillage frequency and external nutrient inputs. However, the impact of these intensive short rotations on soil health, earthworm communities, and soil organic carbon (SOC) has been little investigated and is the focus of this thesis. A field survey was conducted over three years on eleven organic grain farms in Québec, Canada, to assess the impact of short crop rotations without forages (corn [Zea mays L.] -soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] – small grain) on the earthworm community and soil health. Earthworm abundance and richness were generally low in both fields and field margins, with earthworm communities in cropped fields primarily dominated by endogeic species. Our findings suggest that long-term manure application, along with frequent use of cover crops, plus inversion tillage favours endogeic species in these systems. In contrast anecic and epigeic species increased under winter cereals. Legacy (prior three years) management practices were characterized using indices for crop diversity (CDI), soil tillage intensity rating (STIR) and organic amendment use (OAI). In-season management indices, in particular CDI (increased by cover crops and winter crops) and STIR, varied across crop fields and had a greater effect on soil health outcomes. A replicated potato (Solanum tuberculum L.) experiment in Prince Edward Island, Canada, compared the impact of contrasting three-year rotations including one full season cover crop on SOC dynamics and distribution. Treatments failed to differ in soil profile (0-45cm) SOC. Our results indicate that, carbon (C) inputs from full season cover crops were insufficient to offset SOC loss due to high tillage intensity in these rotations, affecting both topsoil and subsoil SOC stocks. Overall, this research has shown that reducing tillage intensity by increasing crop diversity was the main driver of earthworm community diversity and soil health. Rotations that enhance C inputs, such as via winter cover crops and cash crops residues, could buffer the earthworm community, and soil health and SOC, against the impacts of greater tillage intensity in short rotation cropping systems.